Rav moshe feinstein medicine on yom kippur

Behold! Yom Kippur, that sacred and somber day in the Jewish calendar, emerges as a splendid occasion for introspection, prayer, and fasting, as mortals yearn for repentance and spiritual purification. Nevertheless, in the realm of health and well-being, perplexing inquiries arise regarding the permissibility of administering medicine during Yom Kippur. Thus, let us embark on an intriguing exploration of the views held by Rav Moshe Feinstein, an eminent authority on Jewish law during the remarkable 20th century.


Rav moshe feinstein medicine on yom kippur

Yom Kippur, the resplendent jewel nestled within the tapestry of Tishrei’s tenth day, consummates the Ten Days of Repentance that burgeon from the inception of Rosh Hashanah. On this unparalleled day, an exquisite symphony of atonement orchestrates the endeavors of individuals who seek divine forgiveness and reconciliation with their brethren. The rituals and prayers woven into this sacred fabric strive to engender a renaissance of the spirit, forging a profound bond with the celestial realm.

Understanding Yom Kippur

Within the ethereal realm of Yom Kippur, the abstention from sustenance resonates as an exalted mitzvah, a religio-ethical duty, bestowed upon adult Jews, with few exceptions. The act of fasting embodies a transcendence from the terrestrial sphere, an abandonment of worldly desires, paving the way for individuals to immerse themselves in the sublime realm of spiritual yearning and self-reflection.

The Significance of Fasting on Yom Kippur

Lo and behold! Rav Moshe Feinstein (1895-1986), a titan among halachic luminaries, strides upon the stage of history. Born in the realm of Russia, this erudite scholar ascended to the zenith of his authority, eventually assuming the mantle of Chief Rabbi of the United States. Rav Moshe Feinstein’s prodigious erudition and incomparable analytic acuity reverberate throughout the annals of Jewish law and observance, casting a profound influence over the multitudes.

Rav Moshe Feinstein and His Views on Medicine on Yom Kippur

Pikuach nefesh, the sacred mandate of safeguarding human life, ascends to the pinnacles of paramount importance within the realm of Jewish law. When confronted with the fateful quandary of juggling religious rituals and the preservation of life’s fragile flame, the scales of judgment invariably tip in favor of life itself. Within this paradigm, we glean insights into Rav Moshe Feinstein’s profound perspectives on the administration of medicine during the sacred epoch of Yom Kippur.

The Principles of Pikuach Nefesh

Verily, Rav Moshe Feinstein espoused the enlightened stance that the administration of medicine during Yom Kippur stands permissible, provided a bona fide concern for health or life materializes. His sagacious gaze acknowledged the propensity for certain medical conditions to exacerbate or cast an ominous pall over one’s existence if not duly attended. In such instances, the onus rests upon the individual to prioritize their health and seek solace in the arms of medical intervention.

The Permissibility of Taking Medicine on Yom Kippur

Even as Rav Moshe Feinstein extended the mantle of permissibility to encompass the realm of medicine during Yom Kippur, he delineated a set of stringent stipulations and constraints. The administration of medicine must constitute an indispensable panacea for the individual’s well-being, necessitating a conscientious consultation with an erudite halachic authority to ascertain the admissibility and dosage. Furthermore, the individual must partake of the medicinal elixir discreetly, eschewing any ostentatious displays that might erode the sacred fabric of the hallowed day.

Differentiating Between Life-Threatening and Non-Life-Threatening Situations

When the ebon veil of dire circumstances descends upon the human condition, a distinction must be drawn between those fraught with existential peril and those enmeshed in a labyrinth of less dire straits.

Life-Threatening Scenarios

Where a medical condition casts a pall of imminent peril upon the life of an individual, Rav Moshe Feinstein’s august ruling resounds with clarity, allowing for the administration of medicine, even if it necessitates an unfurling of the temporal bonds of fasting. Forsooth! The preservation of life ascends as an indomitable imperative, eclipsing the luminescence of Yom Kippur’s sanctity.

Non-Life-Threatening Situations

In situations where the medical affliction assumes a less lethal visage, the counsel of Rav Moshe Feinstein enjoins upon the petitioner the contemplation of an intricate tapestry of considerations. The gravity of the ailment, the potential hazards latent within the act of fasting, and the ramifications for one’s capacity to partake in the ethereal acts of prayer and introspection must all be judiciously weighed. It is herein that the presence of an adroit halachic authority becomes indispensable, weaving a personalized ruling tailored to the petitioner’s unique predicament.

Seeking Guidance from a Competent Halachic Authority

Rav Moshe Feinstein, with unwavering clarity of purpose, emphasized the cardinal significance of soliciting the sagacious guidance of a proficient halachic authority when confronted with the enigma of medicine during Yom Kippur. Each tribulation stands as an unparalleled epic, replete with idiosyncrasies that mandate a bespoke resolution. Thus, let the radiant guidance of a wise and learned rabbi or halachic authority illuminate the treacherous path.

The Approach of Other Rabbinical Authorities

Whilst Rav Moshe Feinstein’s resplendent views on medicine during Yom Kippur stand as a beacon of sagacity, it behooves the seekers of knowledge to acknowledge the kaleidoscope of diverse perspectives within the realm of rabbinical authorities. The tapestry of opinions weaves itself with variegated threads, embracing leniency and stringency alike. Thus, it becomes a veritable imperative to seek counsel from a rabbi attuned to the subtle harmonies that resonate within one’s own religious beliefs and practices.

The Importance of Balancing Spiritual and Physical Well-being

Rav Moshe Feinstein’s teachings converge upon a poignant insight into the delicate interplay between spiritual and physical well-being. The observance of Yom Kippur looms as a beacon of unparalleled significance, casting its hallowed aura upon the devout. However, this devotion should never come at the cost of jeopardizing one’s well-being or the very sustenance of life. The recognition of the principle of pikuach nefesh, the sanctified act of preserving life, empowers individuals to embrace the imperative of prioritizing their own welfare without compromising the sacred moorings of Jewish observance.

Who is exempt from fasting on Yom Kippur?

In traditional Jewish practice, children under 13 are not expected to fast. Neither are pregnant women or anyone with a medical condition that fasting would exacerbate. The idea isn’t to create a health hazard—it’s a spiritual practice


In the shimmering tapestry of Yom Kippur, Rav Moshe Feinstein’s profound perspectives on medicine cast their resplendent light upon the dilemmas faced by individuals ensnared in the labyrinth of health challenges on this auspicious day. Whilst the ideal course of action remains steeped in the purity of fasting and the immersive embrace of Yom Kippur’s spiritual bounty, the preservation of life emerges as an immutable priority when genuine health concerns arise. Thus, the wise counsel of a proficient halachic authority becomes an indispensable compass, steering one through the convoluted corridors of individual circumstances.


Is it ever permissible to take medicine on Yom Kippur?

Yes, according to Rav Moshe Feinstein, it is permissible to take medicine on Yom Kippur if there is a genuine concern for one’s health or life. However, the decision should be made after consulting with a competent halachic authority.

Does taking medicine on Yom Kippur invalidate the fast?

Taking medicine on Yom Kippur, when deemed necessary, does not invalidate the fast. The principle of pikuach nefesh allows for the preservation of life, even if it requires breaking the fast.

Can I decide on my own whether to take medicine on Yom Kippur?

While individuals may have a general understanding of their health conditions, it is crucial to consult with a competent halachic authority when making decisions about taking medicine on Yom Kippur. A rabbi or halachic authority can provide personalized guidance based on the specific circumstances.

What if my condition is not life-threatening but affects my ability to fast and pray?

In cases where the medical condition is not life-threatening but may significantly impact an individual’s ability to fast and engage in prayer, it is recommended to consult with a competent halachic authority. They can provide guidance based on the severity of the illness and the potential risks involved.

Can I openly take medicine on Yom Kippur if necessary?

Rav Moshe Feinstein advised taking medicine discreetly on Yom Kippur, avoiding any public displays that may diminish the sanctity of the day. It is important to respect the observance of Yom Kippur while prioritizing one’s health and well-being.

Leave a Comment